|
|||||||||||
Genpei War 源平 合戦 "Not just another war over imperial succession" |
|||||||||||
|
In Japanese, the "Genpei War" means "War between the Minamoto and the Taira". Because the events of this war form the base of many a Kabuki play or story, this conflict is know in Japan as a dramatic and important war. However, it was not just "a war" between the Minamoto and the Taira. Furthermore, it is "Not just another war over imperial succession". It was "the war" of imperial succession that resulted in the
Most texts gloss over the "changes in the imperial court". My belief is that writers either A) fail to understand or comprehend the important dynamics of the age or b) find it easier to just preserve the myth of continuous imperial succession and control. In any case, the facts speak loudly and the Genpei War resulted in was no less than a complete over through of the government!
|
|||||||||||
|
THE ROAD TO WAR
The Genpei War
(1180-1185) was the
culmination of
decades conflict
between the Minamoto and
the Taira - the two most
powerful military clans
of the time. . Here
are the sequence of
important events leading
to the Genpei War.
1156 Hōgen Rebellion - Reigning Emperor Leads a Rebellion Against His Own Government. In 1156, the reigning Emperor lead a revolt against his own government. This is very strange concept indeed. However, understanding that the emperor is more often than not beholden to powerful external forces is an important concept for understanding Japanese History. Anyway, in 1156, there was a very short war called the Hōgen Rebellion. In this war, the reigning Emperor Go-Shirakawa (E#77), who almost 30 years old at the time and who you would think had control of the government, actually had to revolt against his handlers (Fujiwara clan) and some of the former emperors. With the critical assistance of the two emerging and powerful military clans of the period - the Taira and the Minimoto clans - Emperor Go-Shirakawa conceptually free himself from control by the Fujiwara clan. However, as we will see, this new found freedom was quite short and limited. Some herald the ascension of Emperor Go-Shirakawa (E#77) and the installation of the Minimoto and Taira clan member to positions high in the government as the first samurai lead governments. To some extent this is true but it is a bit of an overstatement:
The Taira Consolidate Power The 1156 Hōgen Rebellion was followed by three years in minor infighting.
1160 Heiji Rebellion This infighting culminated in the 1160 Heiji Rebellion which was essentially a "mini genpei war" meaning a mini war between the Gen (the Minamoto) and the Hei (the Taira). In January 1160 (late 1159 lunar calendar) the Minamoto staged a rebellion who major battle was the Siege of the Sanjō Palace (Goshirakawa's Palace). During this conflict, the Minamoto were quickly able to capture Emperor Go-Shirakawa (E#77) and Emperor Nijō (E#78). This rbellion was a brief armed conflict in the capital, lasting less than a than a month but resulted in the
Taira no Kiyomori - clan leader Taira no Kiyomori was a great man and had children were a bit more successful, he probably would have been remembered more that way. However, that did not happen. (to be seen later). He was rich and powerful, and this did not happen by accident. He had a significant commercial base of operation in what is modern day Kobe (good port on the island sea) and from there had significant commercial interest that trade with China. He amassed significant wealth. For those who don't know Kobe, Kyoto, Osaka, Nara and all relatively close together. Kobe to Nara is ____ kilometer. Kobe to Nara is ____. Average 100 kilometer from end to end. 1167 - Major Power Shift After 1160 Heiji Rebellion, from 1160 to 1167, the conflicts between the Taira and Minamoto continued in a subdue form. However, in 1167 there
was a major power shift
that occurred sort of
seamlessly. In that year Taira no Kiyomori was appointed Daijō Daijin, chief minister of the government. Taira no Kiyomori was the de facto administrator of the imperial government. This was the first time such a position filled by a person coming from a warrior family.
In many ways (my theory), one could date "military control" of Japan from 1167 or 1168 and call Taira no Kiyomori the first "shougun". However, since Taira was not the ultimate winner of the subsequent war nor writer of the history, it is generally not construed this way. However, even though he never had the title "shougun", Taira no Kiyomori was really Japan's first "military dictator", considering he possessed all the power and ultimately determined who was emperor. 1177 - Shishigatani Affair - Former Emperor Tries to Depose Taira no Kiyomori In 1177, retired Emperor Go-Shirakawa (E#77) attempted a depose Taira no Kiyomori (Daijō Daijin / prime minister). This is called the Shishigatani Affair. The plot was not successful:
December 1179 - Taira no Kiyomori "arrests" the Former Emperor Go-Shirakawa continued to cause trouble for the Kiyomori and by year end Kiyomori had had enough. In December 1179, Kiyomori marched into the capital with several thousand troops and placed Go-Shirakawa "under house arrest". He then a) forced the resignation of his rival from all government post and subsequently banished them, b) numerous high officials were reduced in rank and c) replaced open positions with relatives or allies. March 1180 - Taria Install a New Emperor. 3 months later, on March 21, 1180, Taira no Kiyomori forced the abdication of Emperor Takakura - who was the 80th emperor from age 7 and put his 2 year old grandson, Antoku (E#81) on the throne. May 1180 - "War is Declared". Conceptually the Taira had disenfranchised a large percentage of the imperial court and was fiercely hated by them Prince Mochihito was one of the "formerly in" "currently out" crowd. Prince Mochihito, who was former emperor Go-Shirakawa's son and former emperor Takakura's brother, felt that he was being denied his rightful place on the throne and, with the help of Minamoto Yoritomo, sent out a call to arms on May 5, 1180 - conceptually the start of the Genpei War. June1180 - the 2 year old emperor & capital is move to Kobe. In June 1180,
on the eve of the first
major battles of the
Genpei war. Kiyomori moved the seat
of imperial power to
Fukuhara, which is
modern day Hyougo-Ku in
Kobe, just west of
Sanomiya is a place
historically know as the
Owada-no-tomari (Ōwada
Anchorage or Hyōgo Port).
Fukuhara (Kobe) was Kiyomori a "Taira power base". It is difficult to image these days as Kobe seems so off the beaten path compared to Nara and Kyoto, but Kobe was really a happening place, not to mention very strategically positioned - good port, restricted access from land, closest point to Shikoku - one off Japan's 4 large main islands - on along the inland seaway which was historically used for trade between "Osaka Area" and China / Korea. According to written record, the area has been an active history from 200 AD and the location of numerous old story or folklore. One important note is that people traveling to and from the "Osaka Area" and "Kyuushu" and who follow the coast of foot are push into a narrow strip of beach between the mountains and the water by topography. And its narrowest, it is perhaps only 1 mile wide. Hence, conceptually, it a place that could be defended as a stronghold. This point was so obvious to those in power that the Tokugawa shogunate prohibited a castles from being build there and this "rule" may have been in effect for a much longer time - it just that I haven't found such references. Also, in 1180, records indicate that the Kobe area had built a new port and was the center of trade with the Chinese Song Dynasty and the location of the Chinese embassy. However, another reason for moving the imperial court to Kobe is to even more further remove former emperor Go Shirakawa, whom was still making the usual trouble for Taira no Kiyomori and thus still being held prisoner. The Chinese influence can not be understated. In a passage in the Hyakirenshō, is one of the first mentions of the growth of monetary transactions in Japan. ("There is a strange sickness going round the country nowadays. It is called the money disease.") The use of coins increased quickly and by the end of the 13th century Chinese copper cash is legal tender for the payment of taxes and for use in private transactions. War Begins Battle of Uji Anyway June 1180 was a busy month, but not a good one to be a rebel. Prince Mochihito had fled Kyoto and had taken refuge up near Lake Biwako (Just North of Kyoto) and being protected by the Buddhist monks at in Mii-dera / Onjō-ji at the foot of Mt Hiei. In June 1180, Taira forces went after Prince Mochihito who then with the help of the warrior monks of Mr. Hiei fled south in the direction of Nara. Anyway, at the Battle of Uji, Prince Mochihito was killed along with the then Minamoto clan leader Minamoto no Yorimasa. The Taira moved against the warrior monks of the Enryaku-ji complex on Mt Hiei but were not sucessful. Hence they fough it easy to just attack the southern monks in Nara (see below) whose facilities were mostly in the valley. Without getting into detail. These Mt. Hiei monks show up frequently in Japanese History. Since there facilities are spread out all over this relative large and steep mountain area, they have historically been very difficult to defeat. Seige of Nara Because the Buddhist assist Prince Mochihoto and the Minamoto, the Taira went on to Nara (the former capital) and attacked the "southern monks". The summer of 1180, the Taira large force destroyed almost every major monastery and temple in Nara. The warrior monks really did not have much chance. Temples destroyed included the Toudai complex with it's Great Buddha Hall which at the time was purposively the largest wooden building in the world, houses the world's largest Buddha statue. The Koofuku-ji another important temple built in 669 AD before Nara was the capital was also destroy. Approximate 3,000 monk died. Yorimoto becomes Clan leader & The battle of Ishibashiyama After the death of Minamoto no Yorimasa, "Minamoto Yoritomo" become clan leader. However early on, in what would be one of the bloodiest battle of the war the battle of Ishibashiyama (September 14, 1180) , Yoritomo is defeated and driven back to Kamakura. History as told, says there was a truce and Yoritomo hung out in Kamakura and "reorganized" There were a few samll battles in 1180 with the Taira chasing opposing forces toward Karakura - a Minamoto stronghold. However, the Taira retreated back to Kyoto after the a small "non battle" called the Battle of Fujigawa in November 1180. Return to Kyoto With the safety of Kyoto relatively secure from the Minamoto, the Taira move rht e capital back to Kyoto. February 1181 In February 1181, Taira no Kiyomori became sick and died at the age of 63. Legend has it that at the time of his death, suffering from fever, Kiyomori was confronted by a vision of hell and the ghosts of his victims. Further still, Kiyomori's fever was so high that anyone who attempted to even get near him would be burned by the heat & his corpse had to be left to cool for several hours before it could be removed. Kiyomori's eldest son, the popular and talented Taira no Shigemori had did earlier in (1179). Henc control of the clan passed to the much less capable Taira no Munemori (then 34 yars old) who who would presides over the downfall and destruction of the Taira at the hands of the Minamoto in 1185. << RESEARCH DEATH>> Summer 1181 Munemori inherited a war in a state of standstill - sort of a defacto cease fire caused by a) lack for food supplies cause by poor weather had devastated the crops of 1180 and 1181 and b) lack of initiative on all side. For the Taira in Kansai and for Minamoto no Yoritomo in Kamakura, separated by significant distance. there were no compelling reason to engage ach other. However, for Minamoto (Kiso) no Yoshinaka, a young and talented potential future clan laeader was really no reason to stop. He had led an army out of Shinano, marching into and controled Etchû, Kaga, and Echizen. Minamoto no Yoritomo from his stronghold in Kamakura proposes to the Taira that the the country be split in two however this proposal was not seriously considered. Summer 1183 The summer of 1183 was the beginning of the end for the Taira. That summer, rice supplies had partially recovered from the previous failed growing seasons. Taira no Munemori decided to take an offesive against Minimoto no Yoshinaka position in Echizen. Taira no Munemori dispatched his son Taira no Koremori and his brother Taira no Michimori to Echizen with the aim of pushing back Minimoto no Yoshinaka. The campaign got off to a decidedly bad start-evidently,
Needless to say, the resulting Battle of Kurikara (June 1183) ended as a crushing Taira defeat. It was the turning point in the war. With a single battle, the Minimoto under the leadership of Minamoto no Yoshinaka had gained decisive advantage. History said that Taira no Munemori attempted to enlist the support of warrior-monks of Mt. Hiei. Although the Minamoto had at times be enemies of the Minamoto, the Taira were now more of there enemy. Hence, the the warrior monk emphatically refused. The Taira returned to Kyoto, packed up most of the royal family, and the Royal Regalia, and fell back to fortified positions in Settsu Province (Kobe). The Taira spend the fall of 1183 strengthening positions in Settsu Province (Kobe) and establishing fall back positions on Shikoku near present day Takamatsu.
http://www.samurai-archives.com/munemori.html
There are really three Minamoto "brothers and cousins" that are essential to remember and whose fame is ranked as follows.
Minamoto no Yoshitsune Anyway, Minamoto no Yoshitsune is well know in Japan as he has long been a popular figure in the Japanese literary classic - Heike Monogatari (Tale of the Heike). The Japanese term for "sympathy for a tragic hero", Hougan-biiki, actually comes from Yoshitsune's title Hougan, which he received from the Imperial Court. While he is know throughout Japan, his fame is eclipse by his 1/2 brother Yoritomo - the first shogun. But for Yoshitsune and Yoshinaka, Yoritomo would never had been able to consolidate power. What I like the the most about Yoshitsune, beside the fact that he was raised by warrior monks and taught swordsmanship by the king of the legendary Tengu, is that
Close to my house in Kobe, there is a statue of Yoshitsune at the location of a famous battle - Ichi no Tano. He looks quite the dude! Despite this ultimate failure, Yoshitsune was a hero's hero. Although his accomplishment come mostly at the end of the conflict, Yoshitsune's accomplishments are manifold.
Yoshitsune's Story Yoshitsune was born in 1154, and was a son of head of the Minamoto clan - Minamoto no _____, who was famous for revolting against the Tiara in the ____ and the Heiji Rebellion of 1159, during which he was killed. It is interesting to note that the following the Heiji Rebellion, the Tiara spare the lives of the Yoritomo and Yoshitsune. The young Yoshitsune would go to Kurama Temple and the slightly older Yoritomo, exiled to the island of Shikoku.. Yoshitsune's was under the
care of Kurama Temple (Hiei Mountains near Kyoto) and
raised by monks. Yoshitsune was supposively taught
swordsmanship by Sōjōbō, King of the Tengu w Benkei, a wild giant of a man, and according to "legend" posted himself at the Gōjō Bridge in Kyoto and deprived every passing swordsman of his weapon, eventually collecting 999 swords. On his 1000th duel, Benkei was defeated by 12 year old Yoshitsune. Anyway, from then on, Benkei became Yoshitsune's right-hand man, eventually dying with him at the Siege of Koromogawa. Eventually Yoshitsune was put under the protection of Fujiwara no Hidehira, of the powerful regional Fujiwara clan in Hiraizumi, Mutsu province. Mutsu was the northern most part of Japan and the region the nobleman of the region ran it as if it were there own realm. Fujiwara no Hidehira was the third ruler of "Northern Fujiwara" official imperial governor for Mutsu Province at the outbreak of the Genpei war XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX SUPER EARLY DRAFT XXXXXXXXXXXX Imperial Succession Tricks and the Name Game
Imperial succession in Japan in a very serious topic. 80 years ago, comment such as those that follow would end you up in jail and perhaps even killed, or worse both (joke). This is not really the forum to be discussion it but let me just say a few things: First of all, a casual reading of Japanese history reveals numerous instances of questionable transitions of power. Most of the time decision on who becomes emperor is not even made by the reigning emperor. The decision is made by the the "handlers" - powerful members of the imperial court. There is the "abdication game" - where those with power or who gain power force the abdication of the reigning emperor and appoint one of their liking, preferably a royal infant who is looked after by advisor (regent). There is the "without" heir problem solved by "adopting" some relative. Another option - seen in earlier history (Keitei - the 26th Emperor of Japan) was perhaps to find or fake a distant blood relative to install. And the final option, which we will see in the Genpei war, is just to kill the reigning emperor. Anyway, there are numerous options available to those in power (who write the history) to achieve the goal of an apparent "continuous chain of imperial succession". If such obvious tricks are so universally believed, image what tricks never get exposed!
Anyway, despite my sarcasm. I really have no problem with "fake history". Looking for the truth makes makes learning history even more fun - sort of like watching a show that is a cross between "the History Channel" and the popular American show CSI - "Crime Scene Investigator". Anyway, these and other trick are just standard power plays for right out of the game book used for thousands of years - whether in Japan, China or Europe. To rule people, it helps to have legitimacy. The ultimate in legitimacy is to get your power from god or a god - i.e. "to be the emperor". It also help to have a strong military.
The Genpei War was for numerous reasons not called a revolution against the emperor who Yoritomo's forces under Yoshitsune hunted down and killed. It was called a family feud as to not upset "imperial sensibilities". The only time wars in Japan get called revolts in Japan is when they are not successful. When the are successful, they get called something else to hide the true meaning the event.
Global Context
Naming the conflict the Genpei War after the two families is just standard "name gaming". Most people think such things are all just innocent - sort of random, but I assure you they are done purposely. American history is no different. For example, when American fought a war against the Chinese in Korea in the 1950s, it was called the "Korean War". Most Americans even after studying the war, would answer the question wrong. Closer to home, The war between the French and the British in North America that ended in 1763, the American is called the "French and Indian Wars". Names change people perception of who was fighting an why. Every name has a purpose, but the most generally the to hide or reshape the nature of what happen. In the case the "French and Indian Wars" (ending 1763), the name (in my opinion) hides (to Americans) the concept that the British and French were the "main belligerents", in that that conflict was there 4th war in less than 75 years. Hence, the subsequent British French conflict in North America beginning in 1776 could be viewed the from a America Centric point of view and called - "the American Revolution". However, but for the the French Fleet Navy victories over the British during that conflict, the history of North America would be very different indeed. the British fought the French in what they call the "seven year war", but it was the 4th war between the French and the English in the America's in 75 years . The point is that the Genpei War, by what ever name you want to call it was really the total over through of the power and control structure - i.e. the government.
|
|||||||||||
|
|||||||||||
|
|